Examples of Well-positioned Firms

Examples of Well-positioned Firms
2Bobs with David C. Baker and Blair Enns

David gets asked frequently for examples of well-positioned firms from clients and non-clients alike, so a few months ago he started to collect them on a list.

Links

“Examples of Well-positioned Firms” by David C. Baker for punctuation.com

Transcript

Blair Enns: David, you are about to immortalize some of your clients in this episode on examples of well-positioned firms. Any trepidation?

David Baker: This article came out few weeks ago, and one of the firms that I immortalized, in your words, wrote me and said, "Things aren't going too great." It's like, "Oh, I guess I should have checked with all these firms first." They're not all clients. Then I got a lot of other notes from people saying, "Oh, wow, that's really cool."

Then somebody else said, "Wow, we've never worked with you, but it's so nice to see you bless our positioning. It's like, "Wait a second, that's a little too far." I think, because I didn't check with anybody, people did like to see themselves listed here.

Blair: Turns out I knew a lot of these firms. Some of them we've worked with, some we haven't; I would say more than half of them.

David: Did you disagree with any of them when you read it?

Blair: No, I didn't disagree with them. I didn't disagree with your assertion that they're well-positioned firms. I thought there were some interesting different ways in which they went about expressing that positioning, which we'll talk about when we get into the examples.

Do you want to qualify, what do you mean by a well-positioned firm? What are the things that you're looking at to arrive at your decision that this is a well-positioned firm?

David: Oh, yes. Boy, here I'm just going to admit that a lot of it is instinctive, even though when I'm actually working with the firm, we do a lot of research, a lot of science, a lot of math, and so on. In this case, though, I'm not pressure-testing every single one. I'm just saying my instinct tells me this is a well-positioned firm.

If you wanted to look at the math side of it, you're really looking for a firm where there are competitors. If you don't find competitors, that's not a good positioning. That means that you're either first to market, which is unlikely, or it's just a bad idea that a lot of people have already tried and failed at. You want to get some competitors. I like the number 10 there. I'd like to see about 10 competitors.

Then in terms of prospects, you could get by with as few as 2,000, but that's really pressing the case. I would like to see about 10,000 prospects. If you have more than 10 competitors and more than 10 prospects, the chances are pretty good that you are not as tightly positioned as you could be, unless it's a very quickly changing marketplace. Then there's all kinds of other tests, but those are the ones that are just really quick rules of thumb that I like to use.

Blair: You've been talking about working on this subject for 25 years plus. How is the landscape different today in terms of the percentage of firms? Not asking you to get scientific, but if you have data about it, feel free to share it. What's the landscape look like in terms of well-positioned firms today versus 25 years ago?

David: There's clearly, as a fixed number, there's far more well-positioned firms than there ever have been. As a percentage of the whole, I would say, there's probably a higher percentage of firms that are well-positioned. Part of that is simply that the marketplace has just forced that to happen.

When the geographic moat was abolished because of the internet, then all of a sudden anybody could come and compete in your town, and you could go compete anywhere else. On top of that, the world around us became so much more complicated that it was impossible to really be an expert, a deep expert, in as many areas as it would have called for. We're better than we ever have been, but still a long ways to go.

Blair: Got you. You've broken down your list into vertical examples and horizontal examples. Examples of vertical positionings and horizontal positionings, do you want to explain to the audience and to me what those are?

David: A vertical example would be an NAICS code. In the past, you could safely pick either tech, finance, or healthcare, and your job was done. That was it. You just had to pick one of those three, or there were another 20 choices. Those days are gone, for sure, because healthcare is so broad, finance is so broad, tech is so broad.

A vertical positioning is one that follows an NAICS code or an industry. A horizontal positioning is one that reaches across all or most of these vertical industries and does something in one of two categories. You're either addressing a demographic, so you're focused on reaching minorities or old people or rich people or people who are going to do something like send their kids to college or whatever, or you're reaching across all of these horizontal industries with a very, very tight service offering. You're doing one very, very specific thing for lots of industries. We'll get into those examples.

When a firm is faced with just a blank canvas, like, "We are not really well positioned right now, and we need to be," they usually have a preference for a horizontal positioning because that gives them all kinds of variety. They get to touch all kinds of industries, and that's exciting to them, and it also doesn't feel quite as restrictive. The problem they face is that horizontal positioning is sometimes very difficult to address well. It's very difficult to find your clients. In some cases, they solve that. They come up with an addressable horizontal positioning.

In other cases, they just have to default to a vertical positioning because the biggest advantage of a vertical positioning is that it's addressable. You can find your clients because they're organized by industry. We're going to give examples of vertical and horizontal. Honestly, we could almost skip all the vertical ones because illustrating that is so easy, but I thought it might be interesting to give people examples of ones that are tightly positioned but not too tightly positioned to illustrate that point.

Blair: All right. I'm looking at your list of vertical examples. Do you want to start at the top with Propellic?

David: Sure. They do travel and tourism. Then underneath that, their definition of an ICP is even tighter. It has to be a really large client that's spending lots of money every month and so on, but travel and tourism. That is a vertical.

They do it all over the world. That means that because their geographic market is massive, then they have to have a much tighter positioning because if you're serving prospective clients all around the world, you've got to limit your definition more so that you don't have too many. Propellic, travel and tourism, is an example.

If people want to look at the websites, the article, they can find at punctuation.com. There, they can just find the links to explore the websites themselves.

Blair: I'm looking at their website. "Travel and tourism marketing agency. Don't just get more traffic. Get more travelers putting you on their itinerary." Then, "Our data-focused approach, travel industry expertise, and relentless execution to help you compete with behemoth brands in brilliant, in clever ways."

David: All the rest of that doesn't matter. Just honestly, it's just marketing talk.

Blair: Yes. The way I think about positioning language is it's a pyramid, and it's very succinct at the top, and they've done that. Travel and tourism marketing agency. Then there's language. You can basically keep reading as long as you want, but it's nice, succinct, compelling positioning. After that, you've got Clever Digital. This is a digital marketing firm with a focus on--

David: Home services. They're Canadian, actually. Home services would be plumbing-

Blair: HVAC.

David: -pest control, HVAC. They would have exclusivity in a marketplace. If a plumber hires them from a particular MSA, then they're not going to work with another plumber in that space, but they do this all over the US, all over Canada. It's called Clever Digital. It's home services, and that's a vertical. It's a pretty broad vertical, but it's still a vertical.

Blair: North America's marketing leader in home improvement and services. We're the growth engine behind the home improvement and service brand set to generate over $500 million in 2026?

David: Yes. 90 people, too. Pretty big firm.

Blair: 90 people. Wow. That's Clever Digital, focused in home improvement services. Then we have Venel. I know these guys.

David: It used to be a different name. Orthopedic Marketing, I think it was called?

Blair: Yes. Orthopedic Marketing Group, I think.

David: Yes. Venel was the name of the first orthopedic surgeon, as I recall. They're in a very tight vertical. What's particularly interesting about this one is that it's not a sophisticated marketplace, in that a lot of orthopedic practices have not used an agency before, and they are spending their own money.

What makes this even more interesting, I haven't checked with them in a while, but they used to have three-year contracts, and it was also market exclusive. They were very vertically integrated. They were doing all kinds of things for these practices, including auditing what everybody was wearing in the office, the waiting room. They had a two- or three-person phone bank and would check with every client after every visit and so on. They did everything. You will find a lot of vertical integration like that in vertically positioned firms. This was a good example of that.

Blair: I was on Alex Smith's podcast this morning, or I recorded this morning. He wrote the book, No Bullshit Strategy. He reached out because he had listened to the recent episode you and I did where we were talking about conflating positioning and strategy.

We were exploring this topic of the way I think about positioning is X for Y, discipline for market. If you take a broad discipline like advertising and then you narrow it to a market such as orthopedic surgeons, you then find that the X, the discipline, has to be narrowed too.

One of the things Alex and I were talking about was he made the point that, "Well, it's still just X is generic." You're still doing a generic service for a specific market. Once you focus on that, you start to see these things, these opportunities, these levers that your client should be pulling, that you would not otherwise see if you just saw yourself as an ad agency.

The example you just gave of auditing what people are wearing in the orthopedic practice, you wouldn't invent that. You wouldn't come up with that initially when you're thinking about going after this market. That's something you would realize is important, and you would develop a point of view on only after you've worked in that space for a while. Would you agree?

David: Yes. Right. Usually, the expansion of your service offerings is going to come from your clients, not your prospects. Your prospects don't trust you yet. Your clients do. Even if this is something a little bit newer to you, they still value the trust they have in you, and they figure you can learn it. You know enough about them that you can learn it.

Blair: "37-plus years, the patient growth firm exclusive to orthopedics, trusted by more orthopedic surgeons than any other firm in the country." That's a pretty solid positioning.

David: Yes. It's an example of taking healthcare, which is a very broad vertical, and having a narrower slice of that. The next one, Transcend, is also another example of a narrow slice of a broad healthcare vertical. I just say it's another example of a narrow healthcare choice, but they're really talking about hospice or right before hospice care.

Blair: "Helping mission-driven hospices grow smarter. Is your hospice ready to grow and sustain patient-centered care? Find out." That's an excellently run firm by one Stephanie Johnston. Hello, Stephanie. Kula Partners, also another Canadian firm?

David: Yes. We've got these trade fights going with Canada, so I'm trying to do my part to smooth the waters here.

Blair: By the time this airs, we will be at war. Before it went to air, we were just laughing about this stupid little trade war that somebody, we're not going to name names, somebody picked this stupid little trade war. It wasn't David or me. Kula specializes in marketing for manufacturers. "We're a marketing agency built for B2B manufacturers and industrial brands."

David: This is somewhat of a broad vertical, but they only do something specific for them. They only do the digital side for them. It's a great example of a unique way to look at vertical. If you want to look at something else they do really well, it's look at their podcast, The Kula Ring. I can't remember, but they've done hundreds of interviews.

If you look through the people they've interviewed, I did that the other day, and I didn't recognize a single name, which is the point because they're meeting people where they are deep in that manufacturing field. It's not people that I would have heard about because I'm not in the manufacturing field. Everything about what they do is very, very targeted, and that's a beautiful thing.

Blair: Let's do one more under the verticals. It's a mutual friend of ours, Andy Hoyne in Sydney, in Australia. "Hoyne, The Place Economy Consultancy. Hoyne is the creative partner and global thought leader for those seeking to develop the vision, brand, and marketing for places of extraordinary value." What do you want to add about this other than their work is beautiful and the website's beautiful?

David: Contrast that with somebody that maybe focuses on Section 8 housing. I don't know if you all have Section 8 housing in Canada, but it's basically subsidized side of housing, which is the other end of the extreme here. Whereas Andy's side, he can afford to publish beautiful books that highlight the work he's done for clients because it's all very high-end. You spend some time with Andy, and you just know, wow, he lives this positioning, and everything about the firm and about their space and the way the clients are described, it's all very high-end. It's just a great example of tight vertical positioning.

Blair: Andy's written three volumes of a book called The Place Economy. I'll share this number here because he shared it with me in a webinar I did for our clients. He spent $2 million to publish three volumes of these books. They are massive tomes of books. They are just massive, and they're beautiful. The enormity of the undertaking to publish these books about placemaking around the world will just stagger you, and it has been an investment that has paid off for him.

The book is called The Place Economy, and he's essentially rebranded his agency around this book, for which he is known around the world in this space. The language I read to you was, "Hoyne is the creative partner and global thought leader for those seeking to develop the vision, brand, and marketing for places of extraordinary value," but the tagline is The Place Economy Consultancy. They've reoriented the firm around the fame that the book has generated.

David: Perfect example of that.

Blair: You want to move to some horizontal examples?

David: Yes.

Blair: The first example under your list of effective horizontal positionings is a firm called Archrival, a youth culture agency. What can you tell us about them?

David: This illustrates exactly why it's a horizontal, because it's equally applicable across all kinds of verticals. They're trying to help brands that are not naturally relevant to younger people. They're trying to help brands latch on to younger people earlier in their careers.

Like American Express, young people don't have one of those cards, or The Wall Street Journal, people don't subscribe to that when they're young, or credit unions, which are basically for older people. They're not cool enough for younger people.

If you're an established brand and you look at your demographics and they're aging out, you might work with an Archrival that would help you get established with a younger crowd right out of the gate. That's equally applicable across many verticals. That's why this is a horizontal.

Blair: "The funnel is fucked. We reinvent how brands align with young consumers."

David: We are just reading, people. Don't write in.

Blair: We don't swear here on 2Bobs. The next one is Felix Rossknecht.

David: Not a client, but this is interesting, because they help brands at a specific point in time, but they can do that for many different brands. They're starting to work with firms right before they are scaling, and they can help them scale in any vertical. It's a very specific. It's interesting there's lots of other examples of this around helping brands at a certain point in time, but I thought this was a good one to pull out.

Blair: "Clarity and focused execution for your next scaling phase. I am an advisor and fractional commercial leader helping scale-up founders and commercial teams navigate major commercial transitions. I help teams identify the underlying strategic priorities, make sharper decisions, and align around focused execution."

I think you had another example of that somewhere in here, too. Let's move on to, you've got a couple of audio branding firms in here.

David: This is a firm, a client of ours where we did the M&A work to sell them, FluyteVu is. What they do is they help a brand connect with a consumer through music. They can do that for all kinds of brands. When you look at all of the verticals they've addressed, it's very obvious that this is a horizontal positioning. This is the example of a service offering, helping a brand connect with consumers through music. You could be in many, many verticals to do that. That's FlyteVu and then also Walter Audio, those two firms.

Blair: Then we have SB Expos & Events. Tell us about them.

David: This is not a client either, but I had a chat with her. I added it to my list because she does event management, but she's very strict and says it right on the site. You have to have between 1,000 and 10,000 attendees, and you have to be using a particular software platform to manage your event. If those things are true, we are your best choice. I thought that was interesting that they are so clear on their ICP.

Blair: Do you want to talk about Nancy Duarte next? Her firm is Duarte. She initially became famous for designing Al Gore's TED Talk on climate change, correct?

David: Yes, An Inconvenient Truth.

Blair: Oh, okay. I remember seeing that. I remember looking at that presentation being blown away by the presentation as well as the content, but the presentation itself. Then she just blew up from there. You could just position yourself as the presentation designer.

David: Now it's about persuasion, a little bit more than that, right?

Blair: Yes.

David: When I first worked with her, it was about a 15-person firm. It was a generalist firm. We worked on this positioning. I wouldn't want to say I'm responsible for it at all. She built it and wrote two or three books that basically supported this positioning and has migrated slowly over time away from just presentations to also persuasion. A very, very big name in the space and a great example of a horizontal because it's across verticals. The work she did was equally applicable to a politician or to a tech company like Apple. She did a lot of work for Apple and so on. It's a great example of a horizontal.

Blair: You can see how she focuses on this horizontal and then that effectively split. The language on the website is, "Communication and presentation skills training. Persuasion is power and within reach. Transform presentations, pitches, proposals, and people with Duarte's creative services and presentation skills training."

Then from there, there's two doors in to the rest of the website. I always love this idea of having somebody pick a door, and depending on what they click on, they're now revealing their preferences. One is creative services, so let us design your presentation for you. The other is skills training, which seems to be a natural extension of presentation design.

David: Yes, because you might have a great presentation and not be able to present very well, and so it's going to fall flat. This last example is one of my favorites of horizontal because it perfectly illustrates a very tight service offering across verticals, and that's naming. Two of the biggest names in this space, both are clients: The Naming Group and Wild Geese Studio are just perfect examples of that. Very high-end naming across all kinds of verticals, from software to GMs, cars, across all that stuff, using basic principles of high-level naming across vertical industries.

Blair: With slightly different use of language to describe their positioning. The Naming Group says, "We partner with leading brands to create game-changing names and naming systems." That's pretty straightforward. I do like the idea of naming systems. I find that intriguing. Then Wild Geese Studio says, "We are a naming-first brand language studio." Again, that's provocative language that makes me want to learn a little bit more. A brand language studio that focuses initially on naming.

David: You could see how it would attract different prospects. Those two, both do the same thing, essentially, but they talk about it differently. One other interesting twist about this is that the two of them have gotten together and are doing an event together as well. They compete, but they also collaborate, and they do this big naming event. The second one will be held shortly in New York City.

Blair: What an interesting idea. Get together with your most noble direct competitor and see if together you can create something even bigger. What do you want people to take away from this, David? I guess maybe you're just answering the question once and for all that you've been asked a thousand times: is that it?

David: I think I'm known as a positioning guy. I wish I could be known for something else, but I'll never tire of this. On LinkedIn a couple of days ago, I said, "Hey, I want to do a Q&A, so throw me your questions." Half the questions were about positioning. I don't know. I keep saying the same thing, people. The firms that are at the most risk these days are small, generalist firms. Don't fall into that trap.

Blair: All right. The next time you ask David for examples of well-positioned firms, he will send you to that post or to this podcast. Thanks, David.

Next
Next

Demand Is the New Supply